I threw the three tenured faculty in there because I want Phil Martelli and Bo Ryan and their evil brethren to be out-voted.

Criteria:  If the student-athlete is considered to be in good standing with the university then the 1 year rule should be waived.  Good standing = no student code of conduce issues and academically eligible to play at the time the transfer request was submitted.  If those two parameters are met, the one-year thing is automatically granted.  If not, it goes to a vote by the committee.

Also, every university will hand every recruit offered a scholarship (and obtain acknowledgement of receipt) a list of all transfer requests within the last 5 years and the decision made by the committee.

Right now, I care not about any tampering and mayhem this could cause.  I have no sympathy for coaches/programs/universities.

I'll throw some gas on the fire and say that an unintended consequence of the NCAA's current transfer rules is that they discriminate against minorities.

I threw the three tenured faculty in there because I want Phil Martelli and Bo Ryan and their evil brethren to be out-voted.

Criteria:  If the student-athlete is considered to be in good standing with the university then the 1 year rule should be waived.  Good standing = no student code of conduce issues and academically eligible to play at the time the transfer request was submitted.  If those two parameters are met, the one-year thing is automatically granted.  If not, it goes to a vote by the committee.

Also, every university will hand every recruit offered a scholarship (and obtain acknowledgement of receipt) a list of all transfer requests within the last 5 years and the decision made by the committee.

Right now, I care not about any tampering and mayhem this could cause.  I have no sympathy for coaches/programs/universities.

I'll throw some gas on the fire and say that an unintended consequence of the NCAA's current transfer rules is that they discriminate against minorities.


 

69:  I think youre underestimating the "mayhem" that would result from your proposal.  The unscrupulous would prey on schools doing things the right way and there would be constant recruiting of a school's players.