What are your thoughts on this? Usually we are in their backyard. What made me think of this topic was Easton Stick. I remember a year ago we were recruiting this kid and he chose North Dakota State over us. And he won his game against #13 Iowa yesterday. I had this game on the screen too and this kid fled the pocket and would bullrush linebackers, safeties and cornerbacks. Multiple times the head coach was screaming at this kid to slide or run out of bounds and he ignored the coach the whole game. He was tough as nails and never got hurt but the coach was displeased majority of the game as commentators kept mentioning it. Do you think we need to get back there and find hidden gems?
sure, we live for the finds.
Nobody despises to lose more than I do. That's got me into trouble over the years, but it also made a man of mediocre ability into a pretty good coach. Woody Hayes
Member Since: 8/31/2005 Location: United States Post Count: 10,485
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/18/2016 8:54:19 PM
Here is a list of the players Ohio has recruited from Nebraska under Solich:
2005 Josh Leuck - LT, Starter 2007-8 2006 Cole Bunner - OT, Starter 2009 till he got hurt 2007 Noah Keller - LB, starter 2008-9, 2011 2007 Matt Donahue - WR, played a lot in 2007 before he got hurt, transferred 2009 Jon Lechner - OT/OG started many games in 2011-13 2009 James Davis - OG, played as a true freshmen, injured 2010 Bryce Dietz - OG, was a starter in 2012, till injured 2011 Derrius Vick - QB, starter in 2014-5 2011 Devon Bass - CB, started many games 2013-15 2012 Jake Schaney - LB, injured early in career 2013 Casey Sayles - DE/DT multi year starter 2015 Brian Arp - DT 2015 Addrell Taylor - ILB, has left program, apparently
Member Since: 1/9/2005 Location: Cincinnati, OH Post Count: 1,875
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/18/2016 9:53:48 PM
Can't help but wonder if Easton's parents thought it be funny to name him after a hockey stick ha ha. I do wonder why FBS schools continue to schedule North Dakota State… It's a classic everything to lose nothing to gain situation against them. I would say Iowa was by far their most high end victory in terms of team name.
Say what you will about the level they play on but five straight national championships is impressive. Their program definitely reloads with regularity, even with coaching! Watching a game at the Fargo Dome is definitely on my Stadium bucket list.
Fargo is definitely not a talent hot bed but they do a great job getting the players that fit their system onto campus.
Member Since: 12/20/2004 Location: Alexandria, VA Post Count: 5,152
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/20/2016 9:09:37 PM
ExCat21 wrote:
What are your thoughts on this? Usually we are in their backyard. What made me think of this topic was Easton Stick. I remember a year ago we were recruiting this kid and he chose North Dakota State over us. And he won his game against #13 Iowa yesterday. I had this game on the screen too and this kid fled the pocket and would bullrush linebackers, safeties and cornerbacks. Multiple times the head coach was screaming at this kid to slide or run out of bounds and he ignored the coach the whole game. He was tough as nails and never got hurt but the coach was displeased majority of the game as commentators kept mentioning it. Do you think we need to get back there and find hidden gems?
There is a lot of territory in the middle of the country with just a few FBS schools, almost all of which are in a P5 and feel pressure to dip into Texas and Florida for recruits. Some of these guys would be nice as a preferred walk on since without a lot of offers we have leverage. It's more important to stay strong in Ohio and build a nice Florida pipeline than to scholly too many recruits from random locations.
Most Memorable Bobcat Events Attended 2010 97-83 win over Georgetown in NCAA 1st round 2012 45-13 victory over ULM in the Independence Bowl 2015 34-3 drubbing of Miami @ Peden front of 25,086
Member Since: 1/9/2005 Location: Cincinnati, OH Post Count: 1,875
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/21/2016 10:43:41 AM
Uncle Wes wrote:
ExCat21 wrote:
What are your thoughts on this? Usually we are in their backyard. What made me think of this topic was Easton Stick. I remember a year ago we were recruiting this kid and he chose North Dakota State over us. And he won his game against #13 Iowa yesterday. I had this game on the screen too and this kid fled the pocket and would bullrush linebackers, safeties and cornerbacks. Multiple times the head coach was screaming at this kid to slide or run out of bounds and he ignored the coach the whole game. He was tough as nails and never got hurt but the coach was displeased majority of the game as commentators kept mentioning it. Do you think we need to get back there and find hidden gems?
There is a lot of territory in the middle of the country with just a few FBS schools, almost all of which are in a P5 and feel pressure to dip into Texas and Florida for recruits. Some of these guys would be nice as a preferred walk on since without a lot of offers we have leverage. It's more important to stay strong in Ohio and build a nice Florida pipeline than to scholly too many recruits from random locations.
I think along those same lines it is really valuable/important to have a strong relationship with the high school coaches in the state. We have players who went to the big name D1 schools all the way down to the D5-6-7 programs and Frank strikes me as someone who values all programs/coaches and relationships with them. With the glut of MAC schools vying for Ohio prep talent we need to keep our interests as strong as possible.
When a 17-18 year old kid is trying to make a decision that could ultimately direct where the rest of his life may lead a coach can play a big influence and we want that coach to speak highly of OUr university. That being said I would never turn my nose up at the next Noah Keller that would come to Athens from a Nebraska or Kansas or something = ).
Ohio-The State University
I know we have Poling and some other really good linebackers. But I am looking forward to that next Matt Muncy, Naoh Keller type lb. They are just fun to watch eunning around making plays.
Poling is a big-time player, if he has a Matt Muncy workout. 4.57 40. time, he will go high in the draft.
Nobody despises to lose more than I do. That's got me into trouble over the years, but it also made a man of mediocre ability into a pretty good coach. Woody Hayes
Member Since: 12/11/2004 Location: Athens, OH Post Count: 7,203
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/22/2016 9:16:17 PM
L.C. wrote:
Here is a list of the players Ohio has recruited from Nebraska under Solich:
2005 Josh Leuck - LT, Starter 2007-8 2006 Cole Bunner - OT, Starter 2009 till he got hurt 2007 Noah Keller - LB, starter 2008-9, 2011 2007 Matt Donahue - WR, played a lot in 2007 before he got hurt, transferred 2009 Jon Lechner - OT/OG started many games in 2011-13 2009 James Davis - OG, played as a true freshmen, injured 2010 Bryce Dietz - OG, was a starter in 2012, till injured 2011 Derrius Vick - QB, starter in 2014-5 2011 Devon Bass - CB, started many games 2013-15 2012 Jake Schaney - LB, injured early in career 2013 Casey Sayles - DE/DT multi year starter 2015 Brian Arp - DT 2015 Addrell Taylor - ILB, has left program, apparently
Here is a list of the players Ohio has recruited from Nebraska under Solich:
2005 Josh Leuck - LT, Starter 2007-8 2006 Cole Bunner - OT, Starter 2009 till he got hurt 2007 Noah Keller - LB, starter 2008-9, 2011 2007 Matt Donahue - WR, played a lot in 2007 before he got hurt, transferred 2009 Jon Lechner - OT/OG started many games in 2011-13 2009 James Davis - OG, played as a true freshmen, injured 2010 Bryce Dietz - OG, was a starter in 2012, till injured 2011 Derrius Vick - QB, starter in 2014-5 2011 Devon Bass - CB, started many games 2013-15 2012 Jake Schaney - LB, injured early in career 2013 Casey Sayles - DE/DT multi year starter 2015 Brian Arp - DT 2015 Addrell Taylor - ILB, has left program, apparently
Member Since: 11/11/2004 Location: MAC Play Post Count: 7,713
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/22/2016 11:37:48 PM
Alan Swank wrote:
L.C. wrote:
Here is a list of the players Ohio has recruited from Nebraska under Solich:
2005 Josh Leuck - LT, Starter 2007-8 2006 Cole Bunner - OT, Starter 2009 till he got hurt 2007 Noah Keller - LB, starter 2008-9, 2011 2007 Matt Donahue - WR, played a lot in 2007 before he got hurt, transferred 2009 Jon Lechner - OT/OG started many games in 2011-13 2009 James Davis - OG, played as a true freshmen, injured 2010 Bryce Dietz - OG, was a starter in 2012, till injured 2011 Derrius Vick - QB, starter in 2014-5 2011 Devon Bass - CB, started many games 2013-15 2012 Jake Schaney - LB, injured early in career 2013 Casey Sayles - DE/DT multi year starter 2015 Brian Arp - DT 2015 Addrell Taylor - ILB, has left program, apparently
I'd say that the success rate has been high.
Did any of those guys make all MAC?
Bass was First Team All-MAC KR and Second Team All-MAC CB in 2013 Leuck was First Team All-MAC in 2008 Keller was Second Team All-MAC in 2008, Second Team All-MAC in 2009 and Second Team All-MAC in 2011
Follow Ohio Football recruiting on the BobcatAttack.com football recruiting database.
Member Since: 8/31/2005 Location: United States Post Count: 10,485
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/22/2016 11:59:49 PM
BillyTheCat wrote:
Alan Swank wrote:
L.C. wrote:
Here is a list of the players Ohio has recruited from Nebraska under Solich:
2005 Josh Leuck - LT, Starter 2007-8 2006 Cole Bunner - OT, Starter 2009 till he got hurt 2007 Noah Keller - LB, starter 2008-9, 2011 2007 Matt Donahue - WR, played a lot in 2007 before he got hurt, transferred 2009 Jon Lechner - OT/OG started many games in 2011-13 2009 James Davis - OG, played as a true freshmen, injured 2010 Bryce Dietz - OG, was a starter in 2012, till injured 2011 Derrius Vick - QB, starter in 2014-5 2011 Devon Bass - CB, started many games 2013-15 2012 Jake Schaney - LB, injured early in career 2013 Casey Sayles - DE/DT multi year starter 2015 Brian Arp - DT 2015 Addrell Taylor - ILB, has left program, apparently
I'd say that the success rate has been high.
Did any of those guys make all MAC?
Looks like only 6 finished their eligibility
Two transferred out after an injury (Donahue, Davis) Three of them suffered career ending injuries (Bunner, Dietz, Schaney) Five completed eligibility (Leuck, Keller, Lechner, Vick, Bass) Two are still playing (Sayles, Arp) One left with no explanation (Taylor)
“We have two ears and one mouth so that we can listen twice as much as we speak.” ― Epictetus
Here is a list of the players Ohio has recruited from Nebraska under Solich:
2005 Josh Leuck - LT, Starter 2007-8 2006 Cole Bunner - OT, Starter 2009 till he got hurt 2007 Noah Keller - LB, starter 2008-9, 2011 2007 Matt Donahue - WR, played a lot in 2007 before he got hurt, transferred 2009 Jon Lechner - OT/OG started many games in 2011-13 2009 James Davis - OG, played as a true freshmen, injured 2010 Bryce Dietz - OG, was a starter in 2012, till injured 2011 Derrius Vick - QB, starter in 2014-5 2011 Devon Bass - CB, started many games 2013-15 2012 Jake Schaney - LB, injured early in career 2013 Casey Sayles - DE/DT multi year starter 2015 Brian Arp - DT 2015 Addrell Taylor - ILB, has left program, apparently
I'd say that the success rate has been high.
Did any of those guys make all MAC?
Looks like only 6 finished their eligibility
Two transferred out after an injury (Donahue, Davis) Three of them suffered career ending injuries (Bunner, Dietz, Schaney) Five completed eligibility (Leuck, Keller, Lechner, Vick, Bass) Two are still playing (Sayles, Arp) One left with no explanation (Taylor)
So only 5 of 11 finished their eligibility, that's less than 50%, that is not a good percentage.
So only 5 of 11 finished their eligibility, that's less than 50%, that is not a good percentage.
Yet 3 of 11 earned All MAC. That is a good percentage.
But if 50% of all our recruits are not finishing their eligibility, you will never be at 85 recruited scholarships, so you'd better have more than 3 of 11 at All-League or higher.
So only 5 of 11 finished their eligibility, that's less than 50%, that is not a good percentage.
Yet 3 of 11 earned All MAC. That is a good percentage.
But if 50% of all our recruits are not finishing their eligibility, you will never be at 85 recruited scholarships, so you'd better have more than 3 of 11 at All-League or higher.
Above we have the risk/reward from recruiting far away. No one is suggesting "all our recruits" be from beyond the fertile borders of Ohio.
"Do not pray for easy lives. Pray to be stronger men." JFK
Member Since: 8/31/2005 Location: United States Post Count: 10,485
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/23/2016 1:23:50 PM
BillyTheCat wrote:
L.C. wrote:
Two transferred out after an injury (Donahue, Davis) Three of them suffered career ending injuries (Bunner, Dietz, Schaney) Five completed eligibility (Leuck, Keller, Lechner, Vick, Bass) Two are still playing (Sayles, Arp) One left with no explanation (Taylor)
So only 5 of 11 finished their eligibility, that's less than 50%, that is not a good percentage.
Some of that is attributable to the high percentage of players who are linemen, where I think the injury rate is higher, it is also true that a portion is the distance and homesickness factor, which contributed to loss of Donahue and Davis.
“We have two ears and one mouth so that we can listen twice as much as we speak.” ― Epictetus
I wonder if high school coaches in Nebraska encourage players who are not quite Husker-level talent to strongly consider Ohio.
Given the Husker roster has 8 Neb freshmen and 6 Nebraska juniors with the other classes in the teens Ohio is a very attractive D1 option.
+1
Nobody despises to lose more than I do. That's got me into trouble over the years, but it also made a man of mediocre ability into a pretty good coach. Woody Hayes
I wonder if high school coaches in Nebraska encourage players who are not quite Husker-level talent to strongly consider Ohio.
Given the Husker roster has 8 Neb freshmen and 6 Nebraska juniors with the other classes in the teens Ohio is a very attractive D1 option.
+1
Do you guys really sit around and beat each other off over Nebraska football? The depth and talent level isn't even close to what Ohio puts out yearly. We've landed some really good players from there, but at a less than 50% success rate it's far from a hotbed. We've had as much or more success from Virginia or places like KY.
You guys really broke it down for me!!! Lol. I am not comparing it to Ohio though. I know a team wants majority of its players from the same state but I'm speaking pipeline specificially. Anytime you have more than 4 players from another state its a pipeline. We get some really good kids from that area....nice-sized and athletic. Now if more than have went to jail or did something awful I would say font recruit there. But 30-33% ALL-MAC status isnt bad either. Shows they can play.
You guys really broke it down for me!!! Lol. I am not comparing it to Ohio though. I know a team wants majority of its players from the same state but I'm speaking pipeline specificially. Anytime you have more than 4 players from another state its a pipeline. We get some really good kids from that area....nice-sized and athletic. Now if more than have went to jail or did something awful I would say font recruit there. But 30-33% ALL-MAC status isnt bad either. Shows they can play.
Look at production from Oklahoma. TT, Foster, Beau, & that current RB or WR or slot receiver or punt returner.
"Do not pray for easy lives. Pray to be stronger men." JFK
Member Since: 8/31/2005 Location: United States Post Count: 10,485
Status: Offline
RE: Nebraska Recruiting Pipeline
Posted: 9/24/2016 2:50:33 PM
I was going to say the same thing. No one really cares where they come from, so long as they get good players. Oklahoma has to be the best, by far. Nebraska has been solid, except for injury issues. Pennsylvania was also very good for a time, but then dried up, and I was glad to see a lineman from Pennsylvania in last year's class. My feeling is that Florida has also been very good, but Texas, Georgia, and California have been more hit or miss.
Ted Thompson wrote:
Alan Swank wrote:
Did any of those guys make all MAC?
Bass was First Team All-MAC KR and Second Team All-MAC CB in 2013 Leuck was First Team All-MAC in 2008 Keller was Second Team All-MAC in 2008, Second Team All-MAC in 2009 and Second Team All-MAC in 2011
Another interesting thing is how many of them were team Captains. I'm not sure if Keller was, but he might have been, and Vick was, and Sayles is.
