Welcome Guest! Create an Account login email: password: remember me: BASKETBALL Latest News News Archive Schedule/Results Multi-Media Recruiting FOOTBALL Latest News News Archive Schedule/Results Multi-Media Recruiting MESSAGE BOARD Message Home - Ohio Basketball - Ohio Basketball Recruiting - The O Zone - Ohio Football - Ohio Football Recruiting - Ohio Volleyball - Ohio Baseball - Ohio Olympic Sports... - General OU Discussion... - Website Feedback... - Posting Policy Edit My Profile Private Messages Logout CHAT LINKS site searchwhere to watchcontact usabout usadvertise with ushelp Message Board BobcatAttack.com Message Board Ohio Football Topic:  NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif Topic:  NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif Author Message Pataskala General User Member Since: 7/8/2010 Location: At least six feet away from anybody else Post Count: 9,339 Status: Offline     NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/10/2018 12:20:39 PM  A judge has ruled that the penalty is an unlawful restraint on engaging in a lawful profession. In other words, preventing someone from coaching for any period of time is too harsh a penalty, regardless of the infraction. This is from former USC assistant Todd McNair's defamation suit against the NCAA regarding the show-cause order against him from the Reggie Bush scandal. The PAC 12 and Big West commissioners claim that without the show-cause penalty, their Calif schools might not be able to be NCAA members. http://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/24945390/... We will get by. We will get by. We will get by. We will survive. Back to Top BillyTheCat General User Member Since: 10/6/2012 Post Count: 10,016 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/11/2018 10:17:10 AM  Pataskala wrote: A judge has ruled that the penalty is an unlawful restraint on engaging in a lawful profession. In other words, preventing someone from coaching for any period of time is too harsh a penalty, regardless of the infraction. This is from former USC assistant Todd McNair's defamation suit against the NCAA regarding the show-cause order against him from the Reggie Bush scandal. The PAC 12 and Big West commissioners claim that without the show-cause penalty, their Calif schools might not be able to be NCAA members. http://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/24945390/... Two things here: 1. Likely the this court has NO jurisdiction as this is larger than Superior Court in LA, this judge has overstepped his bounds. 2. Membership to the NCAA is voluntary, and the bylaws are established by the member institutions. Federal judge will quickly overturn this. Back to Top Maddog13 General User Member Since: 12/21/2004 Location: Albuquerque, NM Post Count: 725 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/11/2018 10:46:01 AM  Perhaps, but I think the NCAA is looking at more and more legal challenges down the road. Back to Top BillyTheCat General User Member Since: 10/6/2012 Post Count: 10,016 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/11/2018 11:52:09 AM  Maddog13 wrote: Perhaps, but I think the NCAA is looking at more and more legal challenges down the road. Find me any organization that is not facing more and more legal challenges down the road. We are a society of lawsuits. The lawsuit is the fabric of American political discourse today, if you do not get what you want though the organization or bureaucracy you simply file suit. Back to Top GoCats105 General User Member Since: 1/31/2006 Location: Seattle, WA Post Count: 7,182 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/11/2018 12:06:34 PM  BillyTheCat wrote: Pataskala wrote: A judge has ruled that the penalty is an unlawful restraint on engaging in a lawful profession. In other words, preventing someone from coaching for any period of time is too harsh a penalty, regardless of the infraction. This is from former USC assistant Todd McNair's defamation suit against the NCAA regarding the show-cause order against him from the Reggie Bush scandal. The PAC 12 and Big West commissioners claim that without the show-cause penalty, their Calif schools might not be able to be NCAA members. http://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/24945390/... Two things here: 1. Likely the this court has NO jurisdiction as this is larger than Superior Court in LA, this judge has overstepped his bounds. 2. Membership to the NCAA is voluntary, and the bylaws are established by the member institutions. Federal judge will quickly overturn this. Agreed. I'm pretty sure the show-cause penalty was originally introduced to protect the NCAA's member institutions, not penalize a coach's career opportunities. And really it's up to the institutions to make a decision on hiring someone with this penalty being enforced, not the NCAA. --- To dovetail off of that, I'm really surprised nobody took a chance at hiring Jim Tressel once his show-cause penalty was almost completed. Whether or not you agree with anything he did as the head coach at Ohio State, the guy knows football and knows how to motivate student-athletes. It's a little too late in his career now, but it was always interesting to me. Back to Top catfan28 General User Member Since: 6/11/2011 Location: Athens, OH Post Count: 1,503 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/11/2018 2:59:49 PM  A school should be allowed to assume the risk of hiring anyone that they so choose. It certainly rubs me the wrong way that the NCAA can place such a penalty on a person. Back to Top BillyTheCat General User Member Since: 10/6/2012 Post Count: 10,016 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/11/2018 4:19:30 PM  catfan28 wrote: A school should be allowed to assume the risk of hiring anyone that they so choose. It certainly rubs me the wrong way that the NCAA can place such a penalty on a person. This person is allowed to be hired by anyone, the show-cause penalty has expired, this is simply his attempt at clearing his name. He lost a defamation of character suit in LA courts and is grasping at straws. His lack of employment in the field of football is a direct result from his actions for being a bag man and taking the fall for Pete Carroll. That sounds like a "him" problem. Back to Top catfan28 General User Member Since: 6/11/2011 Location: Athens, OH Post Count: 1,503 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/11/2018 11:37:32 PM  BillyTheCat wrote: This person is allowed to be hired by anyone, the show-cause penalty has expired, this is simply his attempt at clearing his name. He lost a defamation of character suit in LA courts and is grasping at straws. His lack of employment in the field of football is a direct result from his actions for being a bag man and taking the fall for Pete Carroll. That sounds like a "him" problem. I'm not talking about this case in particular, just the concept in general. Every school should be allowed to make it's own hiring decisions. The NCAA putting the "scarlet letter" on certain coaches seems ridiculous. You should be allowed to hire anyone you so choose. Back to Top BillyTheCat General User Member Since: 10/6/2012 Post Count: 10,016 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/12/2018 5:12:41 AM  catfan28 wrote: BillyTheCat wrote: This person is allowed to be hired by anyone, the show-cause penalty has expired, this is simply his attempt at clearing his name. He lost a defamation of character suit in LA courts and is grasping at straws. His lack of employment in the field of football is a direct result from his actions for being a bag man and taking the fall for Pete Carroll. That sounds like a "him" problem. I'm not talking about this case in particular, just the concept in general. Every school should be allowed to make it's own hiring decisions. The NCAA putting the "scarlet letter" on certain coaches seems ridiculous. You should be allowed to hire anyone you so choose. Every school is 100% free to hire who they want, they are also free to join or leave the NCAA, no one is making any school do either. I suspect if the employee was desirable enough and valuable enough a school would make that choice. Thing is, up in till now, no one has found the employee who is that perfect. Back to Top GoCats105 General User Member Since: 1/31/2006 Location: Seattle, WA Post Count: 7,182 Status: Offline     RE: NCAA show-cause penalty unlawful in Calif    Posted: 10/12/2018 8:21:39 AM  BillyTheCat wrote: catfan28 wrote: BillyTheCat wrote: This person is allowed to be hired by anyone, the show-cause penalty has expired, this is simply his attempt at clearing his name. He lost a defamation of character suit in LA courts and is grasping at straws. His lack of employment in the field of football is a direct result from his actions for being a bag man and taking the fall for Pete Carroll. That sounds like a "him" problem. I'm not talking about this case in particular, just the concept in general. Every school should be allowed to make it's own hiring decisions. The NCAA putting the "scarlet letter" on certain coaches seems ridiculous. You should be allowed to hire anyone you so choose. Every school is 100% free to hire who they want, they are also free to join or leave the NCAA, no one is making any school do either. I suspect if the employee was desirable enough and valuable enough a school would make that choice. Thing is, up in till now, no one has found the employee who is that perfect. Very rare indeed. Chip Kelly was given a show-cause penalty after he already left Oregon for the NFL and it has since expired, but UCLA did hire him. He is the first Division I coach to receive a job after the show-cause. And different sport but... Kent State kept Rob Senderhoff on the basketball staff as an assistant and later given the head job after he was given a show cause penalty due to his time under Kelvin Sampson at Indiana. Sampson ended up returning to college at Houston after his expired. Bruce Pearl was hired at Auburn after the penalty was up, the first ever for a power conference member. This link has a list of names: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Show-cause_penalty Back to Top Showing Replies:   1 - 10  of 10 Posts Jump to Page:   1 View Other 'Ohio Football' Topics                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               WHO'S ONLINE There are 248 Active Visitors on BobcatAttack.com 245 Guests 3 Registered Users:   M.D.W.S.T, Bobcat Love's Sense of Shame, OUs LONG Driver There are no other users looking at this page.

Copyright ©2025 BobcatAttack.com. All rights reserved.  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Use
Partner of USA TODAY Sports Digital Properties